According to Zaza Bibilashvili, a representative of the National Movement, the question regarding the recognition of the government's legitimacy is a trap and is unrelated to the issue of banning the party.
He stated this during the hearing of the lawsuit on banning opposition parties in the Constitutional Court.
Tornike Cheishvili, a representative of Georgian Dream, asked the opposition representatives:
"Does Georgia currently have a Parliament elected through democratic elections, a Parliament of Georgia in compliance with constitutional rules, a Government of Georgia formed through constitutional procedure, a Constitutional Court formed in the manner prescribed by the Constitution, common courts of Georgia, other independent constitutional bodies and national regulatory bodies?"
According to Zaza Bibilashvili, this question is a subject of political discussion.
"This question is not relevant, this is a political issue and naturally, we have our answer to it, but this cannot be directly related to the issue of banning a party.
It is some kind of simple trap, that if we say that we recognize [them], then they will say, you see, you recognized us, and if you say that you do not recognize [them], then you will go to prison. This is the choice that the [other] party leaves to society. To the society that does not agree with their political course, to the society that does not agree with the fundamental challenges with which they have confronted the Georgian state," Zaza Bibilashvili stated.
According to Nika Gvaramia, leader of the Coalition for Change, non-recognition of the government's legitimacy is irrelevant to banning parties.
He thus responded to the question of Tornike Cheishvili, representative of Georgian Dream, during the hearing of the lawsuit on banning opposition parties in the Constitutional Court.
"Does Georgia currently have a Parliament elected through democratic elections, a Parliament of Georgia in compliance with constitutional rules, a Government of Georgia formed through constitutional procedure, a Constitutional Court formed in the manner prescribed by the Constitution, common courts of Georgia, other independent constitutional bodies and national regulatory bodies," Tornike Cheishvili asked the opposition representatives.
"I am not going to list individual bodies, you are probably interested in the Constitutional Court first and foremost. Yes, I consider [it legitimate] because the chain to the Parliament, which I do not consider legitimate and this is also my political assessment. Legitimation is not only a legal part, it is primarily political, and whether or not I recognize [it] as my government is in no way connected to whether or not I comply with laws, including those adopted by them, these are not connected to each other. As to the second part — yes, I do comply. And as to the first part — yes, I do not recognize [it].
As for the source of legitimacy of this Parliament for this Constitutional Court, I do not think that any member of the Constitutional Court was elected by Parliament. I also have this formal basis not to connect this Parliament to this Court. Whether I recognize, agree, consider it legal and so on, that is another issue. I disagree with many decisions, perhaps especially those of the common courts, but that does not mean that I do not obey them. These are absolutely different things.
That I, including as a lawyer, have my own attitudes, including extremely negative ones toward specific courts, is a different issue. That as a politician, I consider that a court is a continuation of the ruling link, this is also a matter of my political assessment. My attitude is not expressed in disobedience. Including toward the laws you adopt, because illegitimacy does not imply a complete overturning of the legal order in any country.
Parliaments that are recognized as illegitimate even by subsequent governments through official legal acts are still part of the legal system, and this is always resolved. By the way, if such a procedure is carried out, the fate of the laws and decisions adopted by them is still reviewed, it may be determined that despite the recognition of the government as illegitimate, the laws should still remain in force.
Therefore, I will tell you directly, the issue of legitimation, I think the plaintiff does not understand it as it is in doctrine and as it is in legal proceedings by courts of different countries and by the European Court. I will say directly, this is primarily a political issue, therefore it cannot become a precondition for a clearly legal issue defined by the Constitution, which is related to the overthrow of the constitutional order. I will repeat again: the government is not the state, nor its constitutional order.
The issue of legitimacy-illegitimacy is absolutely irrelevant to the issue of abolishing parties. This does not equal non-recognition of laws and non-compliance with Georgian laws. There is no such equality sign. They are entirely different phenomena. Including, a citizen may not recognize this government as his own government, but comply with the laws adopted by it. These are different topics," Nika Gvaramia stated.
Vakho Sanaia, anchor of the main news program o...
The opposition "Coalition for Change"...
"The 'Batumi Process' has truly be...
Marta Kos, the European Commissioner for Enlarg...
Mana press