Foto

The unbridled conduct of Constitutional Court judges—which they can no longer hide

It would be difficult to find, anywhere in global judicial practice, such unbridled bias as that displayed today, November 13, by the judges of the Constitutional Court. They made no secret of their sympathies toward "Georgian Dream" or their animosity toward the opposition parties.

These so-called judges completely exposed both themselves and the regime, openly articulating the latter’s positions on various political issues. Two judges, in particular, displayed an intense, aggressive fervor: Presiding Judge Nadaraia—who, after these hearings, would be well-advised never to set foot in Samegrelo again—and Eva Gotsiridze, who looks less like a Constitutional Court judge and more like a stereotypical female "Dream" supporter—the kind of person who would be perfectly at home in a crude, unsophisticated environment.

It should come as no surprise that these judges have already reached their verdict.

During the Constitutional Court’s review of the case concerning the potential banning of opposition parties, Judge Eva Gotsiridze compared the involvement of foreign experts in the vetting process for judges to the invitation extended by Slavic tribes in the ninth century to have Vikings rule over them. "‘Come and rule over us’—that is what this brings to mind... Are you suggesting we return to ninth-century Russia, or what?" he asked the representatives of the "National Movement."

Levan Bezhashvili characterized this comparison as a misinterpretation of the initiative. He explained that the model under discussion did not entail granting foreign experts the authority to appoint or dismiss judges. Instead, they would serve in an advisory capacity, while the High Council of Justice would make the final decisions.

The discussion regarding "vetting"—a mechanism to assess judges' integrity, qualifications, and financial status—arose during the deliberations on the "Georgian Charter." Gotsiridze questioned why the participation of foreigners in this process was necessary and to what extent it was compatible with state sovereignty.

Bezhashvili explained that the involvement of international experts would bolster trust in the process and mitigate suspicions that political parties were interfering in the judiciary's work. He also cited the experiences of Ukraine, Moldova, and Albania. Questions Regarding the Dispersal of Protests and Acts of Violence
During the November 13 hearing, the judges questioned representatives of the United National Movement (UNM) about acts of violence during protest rallies and whether the party had distanced itself from such actions.

In their responses, Ana Tsitlidze and Levan Bezhashvili spoke about the excessive use of force by the police and the rights of peaceful demonstrators.

Judge Giorgi Tevdorashvili asked the UNM representatives to assess the protests that have taken place in recent years. His questions concerned instances of damage to administrative buildings and attacks on law enforcement officers.

Ana Tsitlidze replied that the protests held against the so-called "Russian Law," as well as those that took place in November and December 2024, were peaceful, and that the violence was initiated by special forces.

"I can show you 500 Georgian citizens who were attacked and beaten," she said.

According to Tsitlidze, citizens have a right to self-defense.

Eva Gotsiridze asked whether the throwing of stones and "Molotov cocktails" constituted an act of violence. He noted that the use of excessive force by the police did not rule out the possibility of violence on the part of the protesters.

According to Levan Bezhashvili, it is unacceptable to characterize the entire protest as violent based on isolated incidents of violence. He stated that tens of thousands of peaceful participants had no connection to specific clashes, yet the police used force against them as well.

Bezhashvili asserted that it must be determined when the violence began and whether there were grounds for police intervention. He mentioned instances where people were standing peacefully, yet special forces dispersed them and pursued them through the streets.

When asked by the judges whether the party had issued statements distancing itself from the violent episodes, Bezhashvili replied that they had not made specific statements regarding individual incidents. He explained that the party’s statements focused on the police’s use of disproportionate force.

June 20 and the dispersal of the protest at the CEC
Judge Goga Kikilashvili also questioned the representatives of the UNM (United National Movement) regarding the protests that took place on June 20, 2019, and November 8, 2020. Tsitsilidze referred to the June 20 protest as an "anti-occupation" rally and stated that he would not distance himself from it.

The presiding judge, Revaz Nadaraia, clarified that the question concerned distancing oneself from specific acts of violence.

Bezhashvili stated that the UNM supports peaceful protests conducted in accordance with the law and the Constitution, while noting that acts of violence are unacceptable.

Regarding the protest at the CEC (Central Election Commission) on November 8, 2020, Bezhashvili mentioned that he was present himself and that the police used water cannons against the demonstrators without any warning. He asserted that there was no attempt to break into the building and that the court should examine specific evidence to assess the circumstances.

The discussion also touched upon the protest of October 4, 2025. Eva Gotsiridze asked how a call to "hand over the keys" to the Presidential Palace could be interpreted as a peaceful action. She further inquired whether UNM representatives had distanced themselves from the incursion into the palace courtyard. Bezhashvili stated that he perceived the handing over of the key as a symbolic gesture, and that the UNM, as a party, did not participate in the making or organization of this decision. 

According to Tsitlidze, there were differing positions within the party regarding the events of October 4th. She personally supported the rally, noting that this was her own stance. She described the government as illegitimate and stated that citizens have the right to protest in order to defend their constitutional rights.

During the discussion concerning the October 4th rally, representatives of the UNM (United National Movement) requested that Paata Burchuladze and Levan Khabeishvili be brought to the court hearing so that they could personally answer the judges' questions.

The issue of property seizure was also addressed during the session. Eva Gotsiridze asked the UNM representatives whether they could refute the allegations presented in the lawsuit, focusing specifically on the transfer of property to the state.

Ana Tsitlidze noted that out of the 70 cases reviewed by the commission, only 11 resulted in criminal liability. She emphasized the necessity of examining each case individually.

During the ensuing debate on this matter, Gotsiridze remarked: "Do I not have the right to ask a question? Please, try not to terrorize me." Earlier, at the beginning of the hearing, representatives of the "National Movement" requested the recusal of Eva Gotsiridze; however, the court denied the motion.

Judge Eva Gotsiridze addressed the representatives of the "National Movement," asking how the repeated refusal to recognize election results should be interpreted—and whether this practice diminishes the country's political culture and causes further harm.

A pattern has emerged in Georgia where, following almost every election, various parties—sometimes one, sometimes another, and at times all of them—consistently claim that the elections were rigged. There are calls for boycotts and demands that the results be declared illegitimate; there are even appeals to international actors, urging them not to recognize the Georgian government. This is often accompanied by protest actions that tend to persist for quite some time. Does this not, in a broader sense, lead to the discredit of the very concept of elections? "Given the consistently high level of tension maintained in Georgia—especially considering how things turned out for the first president and the second president since the country gained independence—doesn't this, taken as a whole, indicate a low level of political culture and poor taste? And doesn't it ultimately cause more harm to the country than simply exercising some restraint?" asked Eva Gotsiridze.

Ana Tsitlidze, a representative of the "National Movement," responded to Gotsiridze’s question. Tsitlidze stated that they would never accept a reality in which Georgia could not be free and democratic. "You left something out: the third president handed over power peacefully once he realized he had lost the election. Ms. Eva, what are we supposed to tolerate? The subversion of Georgia’s constitutional order? What are we supposed to tolerate? Rigged elections, where the right to vote is stripped from the citizens of Georgia? What are we supposed to tolerate? Citizens of Georgia being beaten in the streets? What are we supposed to tolerate? The fact that we have political prisoners, that we are being gassed, that we are left with no real choice, and that the state has been captured? I don’t even consider myself 'repressed'—others have actually endured time in prison. Do you think any of us *wants* people to be in prison, or for us to be out in the streets fighting? That is not our ultimate goal. Nor is our goal to perpetually refuse to recognize election results. The primary objective—in order for this country to find peace, to return to a path of normal, democratic development, and to get back within a constitutional framework aligned with a European trajectory—is for the citizens of Georgia to finally, once and for all, reclaim the state that has been taken from them, and..." "...to gain a free and fair opportunity. Consequently, as long as Georgian citizens do not possess this right, what are we supposed to accept? Should we accept slavery, and should we accept that this country will never be free and democratic? We can never accept that!" stated Tsitlidze.

Irakli Managadze, Editor-in-Chief